My rarest achievement is from The Long Dark (Finely Tuned) at 0.1%. But that’s because not many people played the last episode when it came out.

My most memorable is from Titanfall 2 (…Becomes the Master) Place in the top 3 of the Gauntlet scoreboard. That one is at 2.9%

That looks familiar to a game I played back in mid 2000’s. The UI looks similar but I think it was white not red. Dark War, or Dark something: War.