I have quite a few creative ideas, but am too tired to write them down rn. I’ll go the easy, lazy way (and write about more legislation ideas tomorrow):
Proportional representation like Germany. In every election, the voter votes for an individual and a party. The individual is chosen to represent the riding through STAR voting (my version). After all MPs are elected, to ensure proportional representation according to the party votes (the second vote that voters cast), individuals from party lists are put into parliament.
This way, we get riding representation and party representation.
What a about Easter is every news worthy? Beyond a losing of water egg hunts or religious services, why would any journalist cover Easter? Meanwhile trans issues are front and center in civic discourse as they are being debated at the frontier of personal freedom of expression. The stakes involved with trans rights extreme to how we structure society and set expectations for one another. Easter, meanwhile, is a non-contentious religious celebration that’s become focused on candy and maybe having a ham with family. No one cares because nothing is at risk with Easter. No one is telling any Christian that they shouldn’t, or worse can’t, celebrate Easter, unlike being trans.
Its the ratio I objected to. THIRTEEN articles? Who needs 13 articles about ANY topic on the same day? And as much as being trans is the trendy controversial of the day, the fact is that it affects a tiny minority of the population. But that’s the CBC’s forte: As ex CBC producer Tara Henley once stated (after she left) “People want to know why, for example, non-binary Filipinos concerned about a lack of LGBT terms in Tagalog is an editorial priority for the CBC, when local issues of broad concern go unreported.”
And there’s nothing controversial about Easter but there are still interesting things to report: Ever heard of the Scoppio del Carro (Explosion of the Cart) in Florence, Italy? A small rocket in the shape of a dove, is lit inside a Cathedral during the Easter Mass, it flies along a wire stretched through the cathedral, exiting the church doors and hits a large, ornate cart packed with fireworks, causing it to erupt in a massive, noisy display of fireworks and smoke and then flies back into the church.
Of course I found that on youtube after a link on facebook. Not likely to see that on CBC.
Do you think a 1000+ year old tradition is “news”? If so, why don’t we have a dozen “news” articles about the opening of every single farmers market in every city across the country, or just as many news articles about the every 10k fun run across the country? Because they’re not interesting or impactful to anyone in society. There’s nothing at stake. They have thousands of firework events every year in cities across the globe. It’s normal and generally accepted as normal. If the powers that be decided to stop allowing fireworks displays, then maybe it would actually be news worthy, as it would be a change and something of interest where the reasons for and against keeping the tradition would be part of broader social discourse. Trans rights important because they are neither granted broadly around the world, nor in Canada. They are interesting because the discourse occuring alongside them is involved in discussions of how we contemplate our identity as individuals. They are reported on because governments are making decisions regarding them. If they are as important as other government deliberations is subjective. Our main mechanism for deciding what is news worthy is capitalism - if it gets clicks, it gets pushed. If anything, government funded media is a bastion of resistance against treating media as a winner takes all sport. It affords a small group of journalists funding and an apparatus to do investigative journalism with a modicum more freedom than most media outlets afford. Sure blacklock might be a small example of other models that can work for niche markets, but their reach and impact (as you note) are non-existent in comparison to the big media corps. We could impose very strict rules about content percentages focusing on local, hyper local, national or international topics, but I suspect you would also be opposed to quota requirements of the like. So otherwise, what’s your solution?
The very root of the word news is new. The tradition of a rocket powered bird is indeed new to you and to me and therefore worthy of being reported.
Haha - ok, you got me. No one could possibly be so seriously obtuse 🤣